Study › Amateur Extra › E9D › E9D07

E9D07

ANTENNAS AND TRANSMISSION LINES · Yagi antennas; parabolic reflectors; feed point impedance and loading of electrically short antennas; antenna Q; RF grounding

E9D07E9D →

What is an advantage of top loading an electrically short HF vertical antenna?

  1. ALower Q
  2. BGreater structural strength
  3. CHigher losses
  4. DImproved radiation efficiency
Why An electrically short vertical has a current maximum at the base that tapers rapidly to zero at the tip, so very little of the structure carries useful current. Adding a capacitance hat or top loading coil at the top forces the current distribution to stay high over more of the radiator, which raises the radiation resistance relative to the fixed ground and conductor loss resistance. More of the power fed to the antenna therefore leaves as radiation instead of heat, which is the definition of improved radiation efficiency. Top loading also puts any loading inductance where the current is smallest, minimizing coil I-squared-R loss compared with base loading.
Watch out Lower Q is tempting because top loading does broaden the usable bandwidth a bit, but the Q of a short vertical stays high regardless, and that is a side effect rather than the principal advantage; higher losses is exactly the opposite of what top loading achieves.
Top loading keeps current high up the whole radiator: more current radiating, less heating the ground.
HamSandwich explanation, first draft. The question and answers are the NCVEC text.
← E9D06 All of E9D E9D08 →

The rest of E9D

  1. E9D01 How much does the gain of an ideal parabolic reflector antenna increase when the operating frequency is doubl…
  2. E9D02 How can two linearly polarized Yagi antennas be used to produce circular polarization?
  3. E9D03 What is the most efficient location for a loading coil on an electrically short whip?
  4. E9D04 Why should antenna loading coils have a high ratio of reactance to resistance?
  5. E9D05 Approximately how long is a Yagi's driven element?
  6. E9D06 What happens to SWR bandwidth when one or more loading coils are used to resonate an electrically short anten…
  7. E9D07 What is an advantage of top loading an electrically short HF vertical antenna?
  8. E9D08 What happens as the Q of an antenna increases?
  9. E9D09 What is the function of a loading coil in an electrically short antenna?
  10. E9D10 How does radiation resistance of a base-fed whip antenna change below its resonant frequency?
  11. E9D11 Why do most two-element Yagis with normal spacing have a reflector instead of a director?
  12. E9D12 What is the purpose of making a Yagi's parasitic elements either longer or shorter than resonance?
Icom IC-7300 HF/50MHz Base TransceiverSponsored · View on Amazon →ARRL Ham Radio License ManualSponsored · View on Amazon →